Khimki 2003

Russie

CityKhimki

Full nameFC Khimki

Diminutive Khimki

Foundation1997

Official websitehttp://fckhimki.ru/

Roster Khimki 2003

Display :

Portraits

Table

Andrey Sidelnikov

Goalkeeper

Kazakhstan

Arrived on : 01/01/2003

left on : 01/07/2004

B.date	08/03/1980
Age	23 years
Height	1m90
Weight	87 kg

Andrey Samorukov

Goalkeeper

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2003

left on : 01/07/2004

B.date	30/05/1970
Age	33 years
Height	1m87
Weight	91 kg

Display stats

Played matches	17
First team matches	16
On the bench	1
Goals	0
Clean sheets	4
Goals against	24
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	1448
Yellow cards	1
Red cards	0
Victories	18%
Draws	35%
Losses	47%

Emin Agaev

Central defender

Azerbaijan

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/07/2004

B.date	10/08/1973
Age	29 years
Height	1m80
Weight	80 kg

Display stats

Played matches	23
First team matches	22
On the bench	1
Goals	1
Efficiency	1893
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	1893
Yellow cards	4
Red cards	1
Victories	43%
Draws	17%
Losses	39%

Mikhail Zharinov

Central defender

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2003

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	25/01/1975
Age	28 years
Height	1m88
Weight	88 kg

Miodrag Jovanovic

Central defender

Serbia

Arrived on : 01/01/2001

left on : 01/01/2010

B.date	24/03/1977
Age	26 years
Height	1m86
Weight	80 kg

Display stats

Played matches	31
First team matches	26
On the bench	5
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	2075
Yellow cards	4
Red cards	0
Victories	39%
Draws	23%
Losses	39%

Andrey Bulatov

Central defender

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	01/03/1978
Age	25 years
Height	1m83
Weight	80 kg

Display stats

Played matches	26
First team matches	20
On the bench	6
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	1962
Yellow cards	2
Red cards	0
Victories	31%
Draws	27%
Losses	42%

Tomas Vychodil

Central defender

Czech Republic

Arrived on : 01/07/2003

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	07/10/1975
Age	27 years
Height	1m86
Weight	73 kg

Display stats

Played matches	20
First team matches	20
On the bench	0
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	1755
Yellow cards	0
Red cards	0
Victories	50%
Draws	10%
Losses	40%

Denis Mashkarin

Defender

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2003

left on : 01/01/2005

B.date	17/05/1973
Age	30 years
Height	1m84
Weight	76 kg

Display stats

Played matches	36
First team matches	32
On the bench	4
Goals	3
Efficiency	970
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	2910
Yellow cards	9
Red cards	0
Victories	36%
Draws	22%
Losses	42%

Evgeniy Karev

Defender

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	19/04/1985
Age	18 years
Height	1m71
Weight	62 kg

Aleksey Kozlov

Defender

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2003

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	18/08/1975
Age	27 years
Height	1m89
Weight	87 kg

Display stats

Played matches	24
First team matches	21
On the bench	3
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	1875
Yellow cards	11
Red cards	0
Victories	50%
Draws	8%
Losses	42%

Andrey Smirnov

Right full-back

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	01/01/1980
Age	23 years
Height	1m83
Weight	81 kg

Renat Sabitov

Defensive Midfielder

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	13/06/1985
Age	18 years
Height	1m86
Weight	70 kg

Aleksandr Shvetsov

Defensive Midfielder

Russia

Arrived on : 01/07/2001

left on : 01/01/2005

B.date	17/12/1980
Age	22 years
Height	1m82
Weight	77 kg

Display stats

Played matches	40
First team matches	36
On the bench	4
Goals	3
Efficiency	1008
Own goals	0
Assists	3
Minutes played	3024
Yellow cards	10
Red cards	0
Victories	40%
Draws	20%
Losses	40%

Sergey Shcheglov

Defensive Midfielder

Russia

Arrived on : 01/02/2001

left on : 01/02/2005

B.date	26/11/1976
Age	26 years
Height	1m76
Weight	73 kg

Display stats

Played matches	29
First team matches	27
On the bench	2
Goals	1
Efficiency	2445
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	2445
Yellow cards	2
Red cards	1
Victories	34%
Draws	28%
Losses	38%

Aleksandr Shulenin

Centre Midfield

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/1998

left on : 01/01/2005

B.date	31/10/1979
Age	23 years
Height	1m78
Weight	75 kg

Display stats

Played matches	26
First team matches	18
On the bench	8
Goals	1
Efficiency	1691
Own goals	0
Assists	1
Minutes played	1691
Yellow cards	6
Red cards	0
Victories	38%
Draws	19%
Losses	42%

Ilia Telegin

Left Midfielder

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2003

left on : 01/08/2004

B.date	22/01/1981
Age	22 years
Height	1m78
Weight	71 kg

Display stats

Played matches	26
First team matches	11
On the bench	15
Goals	3
Efficiency	366
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	1098
Yellow cards	3
Red cards	0
Victories	38%
Draws	23%
Losses	38%

Aleksandr Averianov

Midfield

Russia

Arrived on : 01/07/2001

left on : 01/07/2003

B.date	23/09/1969
Age	33 years
Height	1m70
Weight	66 kg

Display stats

Played matches	11
First team matches	1
On the bench	10
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	361
Yellow cards	0
Red cards	0
Victories	27%
Draws	36%
Losses	36%

Nikolay Barkalov

Midfield

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/1999

left on : 01/01/2005

B.date	02/10/1974
Age	28 years
Height	1m85
Weight	75 kg

Display stats

Played matches	37
First team matches	23
On the bench	14
Goals	0
Own goals	1
Assists	0
Minutes played	2223
Yellow cards	3
Red cards	0
Victories	35%
Draws	24%
Losses	41%

Dmitriy Rogozhin

Midfield

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	23/12/1977
Age	25 years
Height	1m78
Weight	74 kg

Viktor Goncharov

Midfield

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	20/03/1976
Age	27 years
Height	1m77
Weight	72 kg

Roman Kagazezhev

Midfield

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	31/03/1980
Age	23 years
Height	1m75
Weight	72 kg

Display stats

Played matches	20
First team matches	16
On the bench	4
Goals	2
Efficiency	571
Own goals	0
Assists	1
Minutes played	1141
Yellow cards	2
Red cards	0
Victories	40%
Draws	10%
Losses	50%

Aleksandr Makarov

Midfield

Russia

Arrived on : 01/07/2000

left on : 01/01/2005

B.date	14/03/1978
Age	25 years
Height	1m80
Weight	72 kg

Display stats

Played matches	34
First team matches	15
On the bench	19
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	1
Minutes played	1576
Yellow cards	1
Red cards	1
Victories	44%
Draws	21%
Losses	35%

Aleksey Kolomiychenko

Left Offensive Midfielder

Russia

Arrived on : 06/07/2003

left on : 01/02/2005

B.date	12/07/1982
Age	20 years
Height	1m84
Weight	78 kg

Display stats

Played matches	19
First team matches	16
On the bench	3
Goals	1
Efficiency	1466
Own goals	0
Assists	1
Minutes played	1466
Yellow cards	7
Red cards	0
Victories	53%
Draws	11%
Losses	37%

Aleksandr Antipenko

Striker

Russia

Arrived on : 01/07/2003

left on : 01/12/2003

B.date	27/05/1982
Age	21 years
Height	1m94
Weight	88 kg

Display stats

Played matches	15
First team matches	14
On the bench	1
Goals	5
Efficiency	236
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	1182
Yellow cards	2
Red cards	0
Victories	60%
Draws	0%
Losses	40%

Denis Kiselev

Striker

Russia

Arrived on : 01/08/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	02/06/1978
Age	25 years
Height	1m80
Weight	70 kg

Display stats

Played matches	34
First team matches	33
On the bench	1
Goals	15
Efficiency	186
Own goals	0
Assists	3
Minutes played	2784
Yellow cards	3
Red cards	0
Victories	41%
Draws	21%
Losses	38%

Evgeniy Losev

Centre forward

Russia

Arrived on : 01/03/2003

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	03/02/1979
Age	24 years
Height	1m79
Weight	75 kg

Display stats

Played matches	24
First team matches	13
On the bench	11
Goals	1
Efficiency	1110
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	1110
Yellow cards	3
Red cards	0
Victories	25%
Draws	25%
Losses	50%

Nikolay Kovardaev

Forward

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2000

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	24/09/1970
Age	32 years
Height	1m82
Weight	75 kg

Display stats

Played matches	20
First team matches	4
On the bench	16
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	633
Yellow cards	2
Red cards	0
Victories	20%
Draws	30%
Losses	50%

Evgeniy Buda

Forward

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2003

left on : 01/08/2003

B.date	18/03/1977
Age	26 years
Height	1m86
Weight	83 kg

Display stats

Played matches	13
First team matches	4
On the bench	9
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	522
Yellow cards	1
Red cards	0
Victories	15%
Draws	38%
Losses	46%

Andrey Makhaev

Forward

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/01/2004

B.date	13/09/1982
Age	20 years
Height	1m76
Weight	75 kg

Display stats

Played matches	13
First team matches	1
On the bench	12
Goals	0
Own goals	0
Assists	0
Minutes played	389
Yellow cards	0
Red cards	0
Victories	31%
Draws	38%
Losses	31%

Taras Vorobel

Forward

Russia

Arrived on : 01/01/2002

left on : 01/06/2003

B.date	26/03/1985
Age	18 years
Height	1m72
Weight	70 kg

Manager

Dmitri Galyamin

Manager

B.date 08/01/1963

Age 40 years

Arrived on : 29/06/2003

Left on : 14/11/2003

23 Games

12 Victories

9 Losses

Success rate in this team:

52 %

Success rate since the beginning of his career:

41 %

Sergey Derkach

Manager

B.date 14/11/1966

Age 36 years

Arrived on : 10/07/2002

Left on : 26/06/2003

19 Games

4 Victories

8 Losses

Success rate in this team:

31 %

Success rate since the beginning of his career:

31 %

Staff members

Vasiliy Kulkov	Arrived on : 01/06/2003
assistant manager	Left on : 09/02/2004
Igor Yushchenko	Arrived on : 01/01/2003
assistant manager	Left on : 01/01/2004
Anatoliy Byshovets	Arrived on : 01/07/2003
vice-president	Left on : 01/07/2004
Nikolay Kovardaev	Arrived on : 01/09/2003
Sporting Director	Left on : 22/09/2004

Games list

First Division

29/03	29/03/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 1R1	Khimki	1 0	Mordovia Saransk
01/04	01/04/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 2R2	Khimki	1 0	Lada Togliatti
07/04	07/04/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 3R3	GG Izhevsk	2 1	Khimki
10/04	10/04/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 4R4	Neftekhimik	1 1	Khimki
19/04	19/04/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 6R6	Khimki	0 0	Kristall
25/04	25/04/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 7R7	Khimki	0 1	SKA-Energia
28/04	28/04/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 8R8	Khimki	1 0	Lokomotiv Chita
05/05	05/05/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 9R9	Fakel Voronezh	2 1	Khimki
08/05	08/05/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 10R10	Metallurg L.	2 0	Khimki
14/05	14/05/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 11R11	Khimki	1 1	Metallurg-Kuzbass
17/05	17/05/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 12R12	Khimki	1 1	Tom Tomsk
24/05	24/05/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 13R13	Spartak Nalchik	0 0	Khimki
27/05	27/05/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 14R14	Terek Grozny	1 0	Khimki
02/06	02/06/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 15R15	Khimki	1 1	Kuban Krasnodar
05/06	05/06/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 16R16	Khimki	0 0	Anzhi
12/06	12/06/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 17R17	Dinamo SPb	3 0	Khimki
15/06	15/06/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 18R18	Baltika	3 1	Khimki
22/06	22/06/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 19R19	Khimki	2 1	Ural
25/06	25/06/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 20R20	Khimki	1 4	Amkar Perm
02/07	02/07/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 21R21	Volgar Astrakhan	0 1	Khimki
05/07	05/07/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 22R22	Sokol Saratov	1 0	Khimki
19/07	19/07/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 23R23	Khimki	0 0	GG Izhevsk
22/07	22/07/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 24R24	Khimki	1 0	Neftekhimik
31/07	31/07/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 26R26	Kristall	0 3	Khimki
07/08	07/08/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 27R27	SKA-Energia	2 1	Khimki
10/08	10/08/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 28R28	Lokomotiv Chita	0 2	Khimki
17/08	17/08/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 29R29	Khimki	1 0	Fakel Voronezh
20/08	20/08/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 30R30	Khimki	1 0	Metallurg L.
28/08	28/08/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 31R31	Metallurg-Kuzbass	0 1	Khimki
31/08	31/08/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 32R32	Tom Tomsk	1 0	Khimki
07/09	07/09/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 33R33	Khimki	2 1	Spartak Nalchik
10/09	10/09/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 34R34	Khimki	3 2	Terek Grozny
17/09	17/09/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 35R35	Kuban Krasnodar	3 1	Khimki
20/09	20/09/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 36R36	Anzhi	3 0	Khimki
27/09	27/09/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 37R37	Khimki	1 2	Dinamo SPb
30/09	30/09/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 38R38	Khimki	1 1	Baltika
07/10	07/10/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 39R39	Ural	0 1	Khimki
10/10	10/10/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 40R40	Amkar Perm	1 0	Khimki
18/10	18/10/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 41R41	Khimki	1 0	Volgar Astrakhan
21/10	21/10/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 42R42	Khimki	0 3	Sokol Saratov
29/10	29/10/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 43R43	Mordovia Saransk	2 0	Khimki
01/11	01/11/2003	First DivisionFD	Round 44R44	Lada Togliatti	1 2	Khimki

Competitions overview 2003Last updated on 29/04/2024 at 05:23

First Division
mp	v	d	l	gf	ga	diff
42	16	9	17	36	46	-10

Transfers: In

Players in
01/01	01/01/2003	Evgeniy Buda	Neftekhimik
01/01	01/01/2003	Aleksey Kozlov	Kuzbass
01/01	01/01/2003	Denis Mashkarin	Chernomorets
01/01	01/01/2003	A. Samorukov	Chernomorets
01/01	01/01/2003	A. Sidelnikov	Dinamo	Free
01/01	01/01/2003	Vadim Starkov	GG Izhevsk
01/01	01/01/2003	Ilia Telegin	inconnu
01/01	01/01/2003	M. Zharinov	Dinamo M
01/07	01/07/2003	Tomas Vychodil	Opava
06/07	06/07/2003	Kolomiychenko	Kristall
06/07	06/07/2003	Oleg Shishkin	Kristall
Players loaned in
01/03	01/03/2003	Evgeniy Losev	Shinnik	Loan
01/07	01/07/2003	A. Antipenko	CSKA Moscou	Loan
Staff members in
01/01	01/01/2003	Igor Yushchenko	libre	assistant manager
01/06	01/06/2003	Vasiliy Kulkov	Maritimo	assistant manager
29/06	29/06/2003	Dmitri Galyamin	Kristall	manager
01/07	01/07/2003	A. Byshovets	Maritimo	vice-president
01/09	01/09/2003	N. Kovardaev	Shinnik	Sporting Director

Transfers: Out

Players out
01/01	01/01/2003	Zoran Amidjic	Tobol
01/01	01/01/2003	K. Kaynov	Orel
01/01	01/01/2003	Andrey Krupenin	Pskov-2000
01/01	01/01/2003	A. Kukanos	Rubin-2
01/01	01/01/2003	Aleksey Shmakov	Chkalovets-1936
01/01	01/01/2003	D. Strachkov	Belgorod
01/01	01/01/2003	G. Strikalov	Belgorod
01/01	01/01/2003	A. Suchkov	Zhenis
01/01	01/01/2003	Viktor Voronkov	Metallurg L.
01/01	01/01/2003	Aleksey Zuev	Spartak	Return from loan
01/06	01/06/2003	Taras Vorobel	Kristall
01/07	01/07/2003	A. Averianov	Volgar
01/08	01/08/2003	Evgeniy Buda	Orel
Players retired
01/01	01/01/2003	V. Kleymenov	Retraité
01/01	01/01/2003	V. Tsarev	Retraité
Staff members out
01/01	01/01/2003	Viktor Losev	Russie B	manager
26/06	26/06/2003	Sergey Derkach	Retraité	manager

Trophy room

Victories

Second Division	1	2016
First Division	1	2006

Runner-ups

Coupe de Russie	1	2020
First Division	1	2020

48%

All competitions

38%

57%

48%

Average minute of the first goal scored

League

All competitions

Average minute of the first goal conceded

League

All competitions

Most frequent score

Score	League	All competitions
Home
1 - 0	7 times	7 times
0 - 0	3 times	3 times
0 - 1	1 times	1 times
1 - 1	4 times	4 times
2 - 1	2 times	2 times
1 - 4	1 times	1 times
3 - 2	1 times	1 times
1 - 2	1 times	1 times
0 - 3	1 times	1 times

Score	League	All competitions
Away
2 - 1	3 times	3 times
1 - 1	1 times	1 times
2 - 0	2 times	2 times
0 - 0	1 times	1 times
1 - 0	4 times	4 times
3 - 0	2 times	2 times
3 - 1	2 times	2 times
0 - 1	3 times	3 times
0 - 3	1 times	1 times
0 - 2	1 times	1 times
1 - 2	1 times	1 times

Total

Victories

Draws

Losses

Result when the team scores first

League

Home

80%

10%

Away

75%

25%

Total

77.78%

5.56%

16.67%

All competitions

Home

80%

10%

Away

75%

25%

Total

77.78%

5.56%

16.67%

Result when the opponent scores first

League

Home

25%

37.5%

Away

8.33%

91.67%

Total

10%

20%

70%

All competitions

Home

25%

37.5%

Away

8.33%

91.67%

Total

10%

20%

70%

Total

Team leading

Team drawing

Team chasing

Time leading and behind score

League

12%

68%

20%

Min./Match

11%

53%

36%

Min./Match

12%

60%

28%

Min./Match

All competitions

12%

68%

20%

Min./Match

11%

53%

36%

Min./Match

12%

60%

28%

Min./Match

Season formLast updated on 07/05/2024 at 20:05

Explanation: +1 for a victory, 0 for a draw, -1 for a loss

Goals per quarterLast updated on 13/05/2024 at 11:55

Minutes	Goals for	Goals against
0 - 15	3	9
16 - 30	1	3
Best scorer : Aleksandr Antipenko - 2 Goals
31 - 45	6	10
Best scorer : Aleksandr Antipenko - 5 Goals
46 - 60	6	4
Best scorer : Emin Agaev - 3 Goals
61 - 75	9	13
Best scorer : Denis Mashkarin - 6 Goals
76 - 90	11	7
Best scorer : Denis Kiselev - 9 Goals

Last 10 years rankingLast updated on 25/04/2024 at 16:07

This ranking is calculated on the total of league games of the country between 1994 and 2003 weighted by the tier of the competition teams played for. The points per match are calculated on the basis of a 3-point victory and a 1-point draw.

43	Enisey	1.05 pts/m
44	Luch Vladivostok	1.17 pts/m
45	Irtysh Omsk	1.16 pts/m
46	Akademia	1.37 pts/m
47	Zvezda Irkutsk	1.31 pts/m
48	Khimki	1.38 pts/m
49	Okean Nakhodka	1.13 pts/m
50	Torpedo Volzhskiy	1.1 pts/m
51	Dinamo SPb	1.49 pts/m
52	Druzhba Arzamas	1.27 pts/m
53	SKA Khabarovsk	1.34 pts/m

First data collected by footballdatabase.eu on the 06/03/1994. All information before this date, if they exist, might be missing.

Overall ranking at every minuteLast updated on 13/05/2024 at 11:19

Best club streaksLast updated on 07/05/2024 at 20:05

Series	Home	Away	Total
consecutive wins	5	2	4
League	5	2	4
consecutive draws	0
consecutive losses	1	3	3
League	1	3	3
consecutive matches without a win	4	8	10
League	4	8	10
consecutive matches without a draw	6	16	13
League	6	16	13
consecutive matches without a loss	6	2	4
League	6	2	4
matches with at least one goal scored	8	4	7
League	8	4	7
matches with at least one goal conceded	4	4	7
League	4	4	7
matches without scoring any goal	2	4	2
League	2	4	2
matches without conceding any goal	4	2	4
League	4	2	4

Running streaksLast updated on 07/05/2024 at 20:05

Series Running	Home	Away	Total
consecutive wins		1	1
League		1	1
consecutive losses	1
League	1
consecutive matches without a win	1
League	1
consecutive matches without a draw	2	16	6
League	2	16	6
consecutive matches without a loss		1	1
League		1	1
matches with at least one goal scored		1	1
League		1	1
matches with at least one goal conceded	1	3	3
League	1	3	3
matches without scoring any goal	1
League	1
matches without conceding any goal
League

Adblocker detected! Please consider reading this notice.

Khimki 2003

Roster Khimki 2003

Games list

Manager

Staff members

Games list

Competitions overview 2003Last updated on 29/04/2024 at 05:23

Transfers: In

Players in

Players loaned in

Staff members in

Transfers: Out

Players out

Players retired

Staff members out

Trophy room

Victories

Runner-ups

Club overall statsLast updated on 07/05/2024 at 20:05

Number of matches without scoring

Number of matches without conceding a goal

Number of matches with more than 2,5 goals

Number of times the team scores first

Number of times the opponent scores first

Average minute of the first goal scored

Average minute of the first goal conceded

Most frequent score

Result when the team scores first

Result when the opponent scores first

Time leading and behind score

Season formLast updated on 07/05/2024 at 20:05

Goals per quarterLast updated on 13/05/2024 at 11:55

Last 10 years rankingLast updated on 25/04/2024 at 16:07

Overall ranking at every minuteLast updated on 13/05/2024 at 11:19

Best club streaksLast updated on 07/05/2024 at 20:05

Running streaksLast updated on 07/05/2024 at 20:05

Videos

Comments